Skip to content

Independent digital newspaper of Italian-speaking Switzerland

Switzerland Federal Court

Federal Supreme Court overturns ruling over relationship between two judges

Switzerland's Federal Supreme Court has found that the relationship between judges Yves Donzallaz and Beatrice van de Graaf violated incompatibility rules and granted a request to review a ruling. The decision could reopen other cases, including the Sperisen case.

by Redazione 6 November 2026 3 min read

Switzerland's Federal Supreme Court (FSC) ruled unanimously that the relationship between judges Yves Donzallaz and Beatrice van de Graaf amounted to a stable domestic partnership, which the law bars for judges serving on the court at the same time. The ruling was issued on Thursday during a public hearing and grants the request for review filed in what has become known as the pilot case. The decision could affect around fifteen other pending review requests, including the one linked to the Sperisen case.

The rule that was breached

Article 8 of the Federal Supreme Court Act bars spouses, registered partners or people in a stable domestic partnership from serving as federal judges at the same time. The relationship between Donzallaz and van de Graaf, now over, became publicly known in April. The court found that it fell under the definition of a stable domestic partnership, meaning the panel that had ruled on one of the contested cases was improperly constituted.

The pilot case concerns a man convicted of attempted murder in the canton of Lucerne after stabbing a bar bouncer in the abdomen during a brawl. In May, a panel of the Federal Supreme Court that included van de Graaf upheld his conviction. After learning of the relationship between the two judges, the man asked for the ruling to be annulled and for his appeal to be re-examined by a properly constituted panel. The court granted his request.

At the opening of the hearing, van de Graaf's lawyer asked for the Second Civil Law Division, tasked with examining the review request, to be recused, arguing that some of its judges would not guarantee the necessary impartiality. Donzallaz, for his part, disputed the characterization of the relationship as a stable domestic partnership, saying he and van de Graaf had never shared a home or a daily life together.

The ruling now opens the way for a case-by-case review of other decisions the two judges took part in. A 15-page report on the facts, drawn up by experts tasked with clarifying the matter, remains confidential and has been forwarded to the Federal Assembly's management committees and to the judicial committee.

During the hearing, Donzallaz strongly criticized how the institution handled the case, describing it as an attack tied to his disputes with the Swiss People's Party (UDC) and saying his suspension had been decided without any legal basis. He also said he was never contacted by the Weltwoche magazine before it published the article that made the relationship public in April, arguing the goal had been to create a scandal rather than report news. He further said his right to be heard had been violated, since his requests to introduce evidence had been rejected.

Comments

No comments

There are no comments yet. Yours can be the first voice.

Leave a comment