Switzerland Justice and pandemic
Fake Covid certificates: why so few convictions
In several Swiss cantons, authorities uncovered thousands of fake Covid certificates, but only a minority of cases ended in a conviction. The reason lies in the data protection approach the Confederation chose when it introduced the certificate.

The cases of well-known figures from Swiss sport investigated over fake Covid certificates have drawn wide attention. The investigations, however, rarely end in a conviction, because the certificates do not make it possible to establish with certainty who obtained them.
During the pandemic, the Covid certificate was essential for everyday life, from entering venues to attending events and travelling. Many people obtained it through regular channels, while others forged it or bought it illegally.
"Non abbiamo sottovalutato il rischio di falsificazione" ("We did not underestimate the risk of forgery"), says Parham Sendi, head of the Communicable Diseases Division at the Federal Office of Public Health. "Non potevamo prevedere il livello di scetticismo all'epoca" ("We could not foresee the level of scepticism at the time").
Among the most prominent cases are those of former national ice hockey coach Patrick Fischer and national football players Granit Xhaka and Breel Embolo, investigated over suspected fake certificates. The justice system also pursued those who produced the documents.
More forgeries than convictions
The number of investigations varies widely from canton to canton. In Graubünden, there were about a dozen criminal proceedings, and even fewer in Ticino. Geneva and Schaffhausen are among the most active cantons, with more than 400 investigations, followed by St. Gallen with around 200.
In St. Gallen specifically, authorities identified 9,000 fake certificates, but the number of convictions was far lower. The reason, explains Laura Halaszy, spokesperson for the St. Gallen public prosecutor's office, is that the Confederation chose, for privacy reasons, to link the certificates only to a code and a number, not to the identity of the person who received them. For investigators, it would be useful to always be able to establish the identity of those who obtained a certificate.
This was a deliberate choice. The certificates show only the data of those who issued them. "Per la Confederazione, la protezione dei dati personali ha assoluta priorità" ("For the Confederation, the protection of personal data is an absolute priority"), Sendi reaffirms. The goal, he adds, was to encourage acceptance of the Covid certificate by interpreting privacy very strictly.
Marcel Griesinger, a data protection expert, sees a way to reconcile the two needs. Personal data must be protected from access and misuse by third parties, he explains, but given enough time, it would be possible to build an IT system that stores personal data and makes it accessible later, if the justice system needs it.
The Covid certificate system, however, was not designed this way. To identify those who chose to circumvent it, investigators must now look for other ways.
Comments
There are no comments yet. Yours can be the first voice.