Skip to content

Independent digital newspaper of Italian-speaking Switzerland

Switzerland Family law

Federal Supreme Court clarifies criteria for shared custody

The Federal Supreme Court has set uniform criteria for determining when a separated parent truly qualifies for shared custody. The ruling rejects the appeal of a father who claimed to care for his child more than a third of the time.

by Brenno 14 November 2026 3 min read

After a separation, children increasingly split their time between both parents' homes. Today's fathers, more than previous generations, try to be involved in their children's daily lives.

Some parents, however, mistakenly see shared custody as a way to pay less child support: they assume that caring for the child equally, or nearly so, will reduce or even halve the financial obligation. This is not the case. Even when care is shared equally, the Federal Supreme Court requires that direct costs for the children be split according to each parent's financial means.

What remains unclear is where the line falls between shared custody and a simple extension of visitation rights. Since practices vary from canton to canton, the Federal Court has now set uniform criteria in a ruling.

The case involved a father whose son's mother had moved to Austria with the child after the separation. He had custody every other weekend and for nine weeks of school holidays per year. He argued that this amounted to 36% of the total annualized time and therefore constituted shared custody, and had asked the cantonal court of Schwyz to reduce child support. The cantonal court rejected the request, and the father appealed to the Federal Supreme Court.

The judges in Mon Repos upheld the cantonal ruling: «Questa situazione è ben lontana da quanto sarebbe necessario per l'affidamento condiviso» (this situation is far from what would be needed for shared custody). The Court found no arbitrary application of the law by the cantonal court. The father must pay 5,000 francs in court costs, plus another 5,000 francs to the mother as reimbursement of procedural costs.

The 42-unit method

To determine when shared custody applies, the Federal Supreme Court standardized a calculation method. Over a two-week reference period, each day is divided into three units: morning, afternoon and night. Night counts the same as the other units, because parental responsibility does not stop while the child sleeps.

Shared custody is recognized only if each parent takes on at least 13 of the 42 units, just over 30% of the total time. Judges may allow exceptions if circumstances justify it. In the case examined, the father reached only 6 of the 42 units: to meet the threshold, he would have needed to cover every full weekend plus half a day or a night during the week.

The Federal Supreme Court also does not count holiday weeks in this calculation, since it considers custody to relate to the home where the child lives day to day. According to the Court, the parent who has the child during holidays does not face the same «stress psicologico» (psychological stress) as the parent who cares for the child on a stable, ongoing basis.

The ruling will likely have practical consequences for many families: every year in Switzerland, between 20,000 and 30,000 children experience their parents' separation. It remains an open question who truly bears the daily weight of care, and how these rules affect the financial security of the parent with whom the child lives most of the time.

Comments

No comments

There are no comments yet. Yours can be the first voice.

Leave a comment