Switzerland S status
Switzerland denies S status to 286 Ukrainians, including 123 minors
Between November 2025 and September 2026, Switzerland rejected 286 protection requests from Ukrainian citizens from the country's western regions, 123 of them minors. In the same period, another 6,599 Ukrainian refugees were granted S status.
Between November 2025 and September 2026, over eleven months, Switzerland rejected 286 protection requests filed by Ukrainian citizens from the country's western regions. The State Secretariat for Migration (SEM) reported this to the news agency Keystone-ATS. Among those denied S status are also 123 minors, accompanied by their respective guardians.
None of the 286 applicants filed a new asylum request after the negative decision. Only in two cases did the SEM consider return not viable for medical reasons, granting temporary admission instead. For the rest, the negative decision therefore stands as final.
In the same period, Switzerland granted S status to 6,599 Ukrainian refugees, a figure that shows the rejections represent a small share of the requests processed.
Return to the western regions
The SEM continues to regard seven regions of western Ukraine as areas to which return is considered admissible, despite Russian bombing that continues across much of the country. “Singoli attacchi russi, anche se causano vittime tra i civili o provocano ingenti danni materiali, non portano automaticamente a ritenere inaccettabile il ritorno in una regione colpita” (“Individual Russian attacks, even when they cause civilian casualties or significant material damage, do not automatically make return to an affected region unacceptable”), the SEM stresses.
The assessment is based on an overall analysis of the level of violence and the humanitarian situation in the regions concerned. The SEM applies no fixed thresholds, either for the number of casualties or for the frequency of attacks: each case is examined individually.
What remains unclear is which criteria actually carry weight in this case-by-case assessment, especially when it involves families with minors. Of the 286 rejections, 123 concern children and teenagers accompanied by their guardians: the decision made in the name of the adult guardians is automatically reflected in their own situation, without the SEM's statement indicating any separate assessment for the minors themselves. The fact that only two cases out of 286 were judged not viable on medical grounds also leaves open the question of how thoroughly living and safety conditions in the regions of origin are actually verified case by case, rather than relying solely on a general classification of areas as safe.
Comments
There are no comments yet. Yours can be the first voice.
