Skip to content

Independent digital newspaper of Italian-speaking Switzerland

Switzerland Eternit trial

Eternit bis: top court orders new appeal trial for Schmidheiny

Italy's Court of Cassation has quashed the appeal conviction of Swiss businessman Stephan Schmidheiny and ordered a new trial for around sixty asbestos victims from Casale Monferrato. For another 25 victims, judges ruled the case time-barred.

by Brenno 11 November 2026 3 min read

Italy's Court of Cassation has ordered a new appeal trial for Swiss businessman Stephan Schmidheiny, who stands accused of aggravated multiple manslaughter in the case known as Eternit bis. The court's fourth section decided to send the case back to a different section of the Turin appeals court for around sixty victims. For another 25 people who died from the effects of asbestos, the court ruled the case definitively time-barred.

The prosecutor general's office had asked the court to uphold the nine-year and six-month prison sentence handed down on appeal. The judges did not grant that request. The ruling came after more than six hours of deliberation, in a courtroom where relatives of the victims sat in silence as the decision was read out.

The case concerns the Eternit plant in Casale Monferrato, in the province of Alessandria, which civil parties have called the "killer factory". Schmidheiny, now 79, ran production there for ten years, from 1976 to 1986. Prosecutors hold him responsible for the deaths of 91 people. Charges over another 300 victims had already fallen away in earlier stages of the proceedings, through acquittals and statutes of limitation.

The new referral comes a year after the defence won annulment of the trial on procedural grounds, because the conviction ruling had not been translated into German. The translated text was filed in April, and the defendant's lawyers appealed to the Court of Cassation in May.

Reactions from families and former workers

Outside the court, relatives of the victims had displayed a banner reading "Giustizia, Ricerca, Bonifiche" ("Justice, Research, Clean-up"). After the ruling, they said they struggled to understand the decision, according to the Italian news agency askanews. A delegation from the association of asbestos victims' families of Casale Monferrato was also present.

Civil party lawyer Giacomo Mattalia described the ruling as a major disappointment for the victims and said he would challenge the judgments if necessary. He explained that a new trial had been ordered for most of the cases, while another group was closed due to the statute of limitations. Two cases involving workers were decided only for civil purposes, since they became time-barred during the proceedings.

Gianni Crisafulli, a former deputy mayor of Casale Monferrato, recalled that people in the town continue to die of mesothelioma, with nearly 50 deaths a year and around 3,000 victims in total since the start of the asbestos crisis, including people who never worked at the factory. Nicola Pondrano, a former Eternit worker, spoke of an injustice tied to how long it takes to reach a final verdict, warning that more cases risk becoming time-barred.

The case is part of the broader Eternit investigation opened by Turin prosecutors in 2004. An earlier line of proceedings, over the environmental disaster, was closed in 2015 after the Court of Cassation ruled it time-barred. In this second line, Schmidheiny was found guilty on appeal of manslaughter, after prosecutors had sought a conviction for homicide with "dolo eventuale" (a form of advertent recklessness), a more serious charge.

Comments

1 comment
  1. Georges A

    Je me souviens très bien de l'origine de ce procès A la suite du délibéré de première instance on avait crié victoire au nom des victimes, malheureusement l'application des rendus a été moins réjouissante. espérons que cet appel rendra justice

Leave a comment