Skip to content

Independent digital newspaper of Italian-speaking Switzerland

Canton Public appointments

Hospita case: no deal, but criticism of how appointments are made

Ticino's parliamentary inquiry commission into the Hospita case rules out a collusive deal behind the appointments of Alvaro Camponovo, Sabrina Aldi and Eolo Alberti, but criticises a system in which candidates are chosen for political reasons before any checks take place. The report calls for a framework law on public appointments.

by Redazione 11 November 2026 3 min read

Ticino's parliamentary inquiry commission (CPI) into the Hospita case has concluded its work without finding evidence of a "deal" — the alleged exchange of favours that, for two years, was thought to lie behind three public appointments: that of Alvaro Camponovo as public prosecutor, that of Sabrina Aldi as director of Hospita, and that of Eolo Alberti to the board of the cantonal hospital authority (EOC). The commission, chaired by Liberal-Radical MP Natalia Ferrara, instead identified a broader problem: in Ticino's public appointments, candidates are chosen for political reasons first, and checks are carried out afterwards merely to confirm that choice.

The 300-page report, the result of eight months of work, 27 meetings and 12 hearings, focuses on the case of Eolo Alberti, former mayor of Bioggio and former member of the Lega in Ticino's parliament, now facing charges of misappropriation, disloyal management and forgery of documents.

For two years it was claimed that a pact had been sealed over lunch at a restaurant in Lugano on 25 October 2023. The commission does not confirm this: Aldi's appointment had already been announced on 19 October, and the lunch invitation named only her and Claudio Camponovo. Alvaro Camponovo's name was reportedly added later, from an account the police trace back to Alberti — a point now under investigation by the public prosecutor's office. Alberti does not recall the change and, if it happened, considers it irrelevant, since Alvaro was present at the lunch anyway. He is presumed innocent.

The name comes before the checks

Between late September and early October 2023, Alberti's name replaced that of architect Bruno Buzzini, who had initially been proposed, after indications from the Lega's parliamentary group. Officials immediately noted that Alberti was not eligible, since he was a member of parliament, director and shareholder of Hospita, and subsequent work focused on making him eligible, including through documents over which he is now accused of having produced a forged signature of Claudio Camponovo. EOC president Paolo Sanvido had advised in writing against the candidacy, but his note did not formally reach the full cantonal government. After the election, no one checked whether the incompatibility had actually been resolved.

According to the commission, the mechanism is not limited to the Lega: several cantonal ministers act as channels for their parties' candidates, and invoking party quotas becomes an alibi when it justifies not just the quotas but individual names as well. Parliament elected Alberti, who placed third with 57 votes, without the proposal passing through any committee or any information being requested.

The commission finds no legal breaches regarding conflicts of interest. While ruling out any sharing of favours, it does consider it inappropriate that Sabrina Aldi supported the magistrate's appointment while sitting on the justice committee and working for her father's clinic. Criticism on grounds of propriety also extends to Norman Gobbi, Alessandro Mazzoleni and Enea Petrini, over a private inquiry conducted within the Lega, and to the entire cantonal government, for its silence on the matter.

To prevent similar cases, the commission proposes a framework law on public appointments, with preliminary verification of requirements, and the possibility of suspending or removing board members at the EOC, BancaStato and other public bodies, asking parliament to vote on an urgency clause. The cantonal government says it agrees in principle but prefers the ordinary procedure, to consult the bodies involved. Lega coordinator Daniele Piccaluga welcomes the absence of a deal; Eolo Alberti disputes the report, pointing to inaccuracies and unproven conclusions. The matter returns to parliament on 23 November.

Comments

No comments

There are no comments yet. Yours can be the first voice.

Leave a comment